"Not
Your
Father's
Marijuana"
Canard
Again
Exposed
--
This
Time
by
DEA
2/4/05
https://stopthedrugwar.org/chronicle-old/373/marijuanapotency.shtml
The refrain is familiar:
The marijuana of today is worthy of increased concern because it is so
much more potent than the pot smoked by the hippies of yore, who are the
parents and grandparents of today. Today's marijuana is eight, 16,
25, or even 50 times as potent as in the good old days, warn
public health web sites and "experts." All of these "experts,"
as well as a whole army of anti-drug crusaders who continue to promote
the "not your father's marijuana" line, took their cue from Office
of National Drug Control Policy head John Walters, who a little more
than two years ago warned that "the potency of available marijuana has
not merely 'doubled,' but increased as much as 30 times."
Drug czar Walters and the
ONDCP have since backed away from that wildly exaggerated claim.
According to the ONDCP web site now, "the average potency of samples of
all cannabis types increased from 3% in 1991 to 5.2% in 2001... The concentration
of THC in sinsemilla was about 6% in the late 1970s and early 1980s, and
averaged more than 9% in 2001."
But such lies, distortions,
and half-truths have a long shelf life, so it is worth noting that this
particular myth has again been essentially debunked, this time by the Drug
Enforcement Administration (DEA). In its annual Drugs
of Abuse report released last month, the DEA reported on the potency
of marijuana seized between 1998 and 2002. While the anti-drug agency
attempted to use the findings to make the case that domestically grown
marijuana is becoming stronger, the real news is the overall potency findings:
"Although marijuana grown
in the United States was once considered inferior because of a low concentration
of THC, advancements in plant selection and cultivation have resulted in
higher THC-containing domestic marijuana," the report argued. "In
1974, the average THC content of illicit marijuana was less than one percent.
Today most commercial grade marijuana from Mexico/Columbia and domestic
outdoor cultivated marijuana has an average THC content of about four to
six percent. Between 1998 and 2002, NIDA-sponsored Marijuana Potency
Monitoring System (MPMP) analyzed 4,603 domestic samples. Of those samples,
379 tested over 15 percent THC, 69 samples tested between 20 and 25 percent
THC and four samples tested over 25 percent THC."
Leaving aside the astounding
claim that the pot that stoned the hippies was less than one percent THC,
what the MPMP figures cited by the DEA show is that less than 10 percent
of the seized samples came in above 15 percent -- a somewhat arbitrary
dividing line between commercial and high-grade, high-dollar boutique marijuana.
This is not to say that high-THC marijuana doesn't exist -- it certainly
does -- but it is not the stuff smoked by the vast majority of marijuana
consumers in the US, and is even less likely to be the weed of choice for
penny-pinching teenage pot-smokers.
"This is not at all surprising,"
said Chris Conrad, an internationally
known cannabis consultant who has testified as an expert witness in dozens
of California marijuana cases. "It is consistent with the reports
from NIDA that show most marijuana seized as average potency, with a small
percentage that is fairly strong. These government claims of wildly
increased potency being widely consumed just don't have much credibility."
Still, Conrad suggested,
government marijuana testers are skewing the results vis a vis older samples
to hype the "stronger marijuana" threat. "They manipulate the numbers
to get the higher THC percentages," he told DRCNet. "They originally
included stems, seeds, and leaf in the samples they tested, but now they're
just testing the buds, so the percentage is naturally increasing."
Be that as it may, another
expert marijuana cultivator, Philippe Lucas of the Vancouver
Island Compassion Society, told DRCNet the DEA figures were similar
to those reported by the Canadian Royal Mounted Police. "These stats
are a little bit older than the DEA figures," he said, "but out of more
than the 3,000 samples, only eight came in at more than 20 percent THC.
It is simply ridiculous to assume a tripling of potency in mass market
marijuana since then."
What the figures mean, said
Lucas, is that "sadly, around 90% of Americans are still smoking schwag."
Conrad concurred. "I
still talk to a lot of people who are consuming the Mexican brick weed,"
he said. Conrad lives and works in the San Francisco Bay area, a
hotbed of high-grade marijuana production, but even there, Mexican still
reigns supreme.
According to the US government,
and despite the hype about the threat of the dreaded (or much vaunted,
depending on one's perspective) "BC Bud," only about two percent of US
marijuana imports are coming from Canada. Mexico is the dominant
marijuana exporter to the US, with annual seizures in the hundreds of tons,
compared with much smaller numbers from Canada.
But while experts like Conrad
and Lucas argue convincingly that most marijuana consumed in the US is
commercial grade Mexican or American outdoor with similar potency levels,
by no means do they deny the existence of superior strains. Quite
the contrary. "At the Vancouver Island Compassion Society," said
Lucas, "we have had over 100 tests done on about 35 different genetics
we are currently producing, and only one of our strains (a Blueberry) has
consistently tested below 15 percent THC. Our strongest strains (Sweet
Skunk, Romulan, God, and varied crosses) have all tested over 20 percent,
although we have yet to break the 25 percent barrier."
That marijuana is destined
for medical users, and for them, high-potency marijuana is a good thing,
said Lucas. "When it comes to medical use, stronger cannabis is better
cannabis. People self-titrate to achieve the desired dose.
With stronger cannabis, they get the amount of THC they need by using less
cannabis. Similarly, I have seen studies that show stronger cannabis
has a lower tar to weight ratio than weaker cannabis," he said. "An
increase in cannabis potency may be viewed as a threat by the US government,
but it is a boon for medical users." That's right, said Conrad.
"You want to get the THC compounds while minimizing the amount of smoke
and exposure to potentially carcinogenic matter. It is an odd thing
to argue that medicines should be weaker."
Still, the "not your father's
marijuana" argument remains an oft-used arrow in the prohibitionist quiver
-- one that must be blunted as long as it continues to be made, and not
merely by denying that high-potency pot exists. "This argument is
one that just keeps circulating and coming back. As with other debunked
theories like the stepping stone theory, it just keeps popping up every
few years," said Lucas. "It's amazing that we are still rehashing
this. In terms of scientific research, there is absolutely no suggestion
that we should be concerned about greater potential for dependency, no
indication it is more addictive, no suggestions that a higher level of
cannabinoids are more harmful. This stronger cannabis is somehow
more dangerous is a straw man argument."
-- END --
Issue #373
-- 2/4/05
Drug
War
Chronicle's
Phil
Smith
Featured
in
New
Book
--
"Under
The
Influence"
Available
as
DRCNet
Premium
|
Editorial:
DEA
Has
Stepped
In
It
This
Time
|
"Not
Your
Father's
Marijuana"
Canard
Again
Exposed
--
This
Time
by
DEA
|
Never
Say
Die:
Nevada
Marijuana
Regulation
Initiative
is
Back
After
Favorable
Federal
Court
Ruling
|
DRCNet
Interview:
Roger
Goodman,
King
County
Bar
Association
Drug
Policy
Project
|
Blogging:
Mobile,
Alabama
Police
Chief
Stuck
"Inside
the
Box"
Over
City's
Rising
Drug
Trade
Violence,
and
More
|
Newsbrief:
This
Week's
Corrupt
Cops
Stories
|
Newsbrief:
DEA
Pain
FAQ
Retract
Flap
Fallout
Continues
--
Criticism
Comes
from
Unexpected
Direction
as
Agency
Seeks
Comments
|
Newsbrief:
HEA
Repeal
Picking
Up
Steam
--
Congressional
Advisory
Committee,
Arizona
Legislators
Urge
Rescinding
of
Souder's
Law
|
Newsbrief:
DEA
Must
Pay
Hemp
Industry
Plaintiff's
Legal
Bills,
Court
Rules
|
Newsbrief:
Indiana
Official
Calls
for
National
Agency
to
Provide
Drugs
to
Addicts
|
Newsbrief:
In
Swan
Song,
Ashcroft
Calls
for
Harsher
Sentences,
Chastizes
Foes
|
Newsbrief:
Man
Bites
Dog!
Arkansas
Bill
to
Lower
Meth
Sentences
Moves
Forward
|
Newsbrief:
London
Top
Cop
Warns
He
Will
Target
Casual
Cocaine
Users
|
Newsbrief:
Belgian
Cannabis
Clarification
Now
in
Effect
|
Newsbrief:
Spanish
Pharmacies
to
Begin
Selling
Medical
Marijuana
|
Newsbrief:
Safe
Injection
Site
Opens
in
Oslo
|
Newsbrief:
Rastas,
Watch
Out
At
Ethiopian
Marley
Fest,
State
Department
Warns
|
Newsbrief:
India
Narcs
Set
Off
Prescription
Drug
Panic
|
This
Week
in
History
|
The
Reformer's
Calendar
|
|
This issue -- main page
This issue -- single-file printer version
Drug War Chronicle -- main page
Chronicle archives
|
PERMISSION to reprint or
redistribute any or all of the contents of Drug War Chronicle (formerly The Week Online with DRCNet is hereby
granted. We ask that any use of these materials include proper credit and,
where appropriate, a link to one or more of our web sites. If your
publication customarily pays for publication, DRCNet requests checks
payable to the organization. If your publication does not pay for
materials, you are free to use the materials gratis. In all cases, we
request notification for our records, including physical copies where
material has appeared in print. Contact: StoptheDrugWar.org: the Drug Reform Coordination Network,
P.O. Box 18402, Washington, DC 20036, (202) 293-8340 (voice), (202)
293-8344 (fax), e-mail [email protected]. Thank
you.
Articles of a purely
educational nature in Drug War Chronicle appear courtesy of the DRCNet
Foundation, unless otherwise noted.
|