Newsbrief: Federal Appeals Court Says Nervousness Not Enough to Prompt Driver Search 10/31/03

Drug War Chronicle, recent top items


recent blog posts "In the Trenches" activist feed


Being nervous during a traffic stop is not enough grounds for police to detain and search a driver, a federal appeals court ruled last week. In a decision handed down on October 22, the 11th US Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed federal prosecutors' appeal of a lower court ruling throwing out the evidence against two Alabama men after an Alabama state trooper cited only the driver's "nervousness" and "a hunch" for holding them after he had finished writing the ticket for which they had been stopped.

Trooper John Colston testified that he initially stopped Jessie Perkins Jr. and passenger Johnny Scott because their car had drifted onto the shoulder of Interstate 20. After determining that Perkins was not intoxicated or too sleepy to drive, Colston wrote him a warning ticket. But Colson noted that Perkins seemed nervous, breathed rapidly, was evasive, and gave slightly different answers to questions about his destination than did Scott. Colson repeatedly asked both men if they were carrying drugs, and both repeatedly denied they were. Perkins also repeatedly refused to consent to a search of the vehicle -- until Colson threatened to call in a drug dog, at which point Perkins caved and admitted they had drugs hidden in the console. Colson testified that the men were not free to leave as he questioned them after writing the warning ticket.

That was going too far, said the 11th Circuit. Citing the venerable Terry vs. Ohio case as controlling, the court noted that "a traffic stop must be 'reasonably related in scope to the circumstances which justified the interference in the first place'" and "may not 'last any longer than necessary to process the traffic violation' unless there is articulable suspicion of other illegal activity." In other words, Trooper Colston was bound by law to let the men be on their way once he had written the warning ticket because he could not say he had any knowledge of any illegal activity, merely a hunch.

The government argued that Perkins' nervousness and evasiveness were grounds enough to meet the bar of "reasonable suspicion" that a crime was being committed, but the 11th Circuit did not buy that argument. "There is no reason why Colston should have reasonably suspected that Perkins' nervousness was tied to anything other than the fact that he was being detained by an authority figure with police power over him," the court's opinion noted.

The court also addressed the fact that Trooper Colston's hunch that Perkins and Scott were carrying drugs was ultimately proven correct. That is "irrelevant for Fourth Amendment purposes," the court opined. "To hold otherwise would open the door to patently illegal searches by government officials, who would attempt to justify the legality of their conduct after-the-fact."

The 11th US Circuit Court of Appeals decision is binding on federal courts in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Visit to read the opinion online.

-- END --
Link to Drug War Facts
Please make a generous donation to support Drug War Chronicle in 2007!          

PERMISSION to reprint or redistribute any or all of the contents of Drug War Chronicle (formerly The Week Online with DRCNet is hereby granted. We ask that any use of these materials include proper credit and, where appropriate, a link to one or more of our web sites. If your publication customarily pays for publication, DRCNet requests checks payable to the organization. If your publication does not pay for materials, you are free to use the materials gratis. In all cases, we request notification for our records, including physical copies where material has appeared in print. Contact: the Drug Reform Coordination Network, P.O. Box 18402, Washington, DC 20036, (202) 293-8340 (voice), (202) 293-8344 (fax), e-mail [email protected]. Thank you.

Articles of a purely educational nature in Drug War Chronicle appear courtesy of the DRCNet Foundation, unless otherwise noted.

Issue #307, 10/17/03 Editorial: It's Time to Rejoin the Free World | Presenting "BUSTED: The Citizen's Guide to Surviving Police Encounters" | Decriminalization Comes to Britain: House of Commons Passes Cannabis Rescheduling Bill | Leftist Legalizer Elected Mayor of Bogota in Voter Rebuke of Colombian President | Dutch Government Seeks Ban on Foreigners in Coffee Shops | One and a Half Million Drug Arrests Last Year, Nearly 700,000 for Marijuana, FBI Reports | Media Scan: David Borden on Cultural Baggage, Forbes, Alternet, Pot TV | This Week in History | Newsbrief: MAPS/UMass Marijuana Grow Proposal Gets Backing from Senators Kennedy and Kerry | Newsbrief: This Week's Corrupt Cops Story | Newsbrief: Campaign Comments -- Lieberman on Drug War Racial Disparities | Newsbrief: Federal Appeals Court Says Nervousness Not Enough to Prompt Driver Search | Newsbrief: More Death Squad Drug Killings in the Philippines | Newsbrief: Retrograde Drug Politics in Kentucky Governor's Race | Newsbrief: North Carolina Congressman in Drug Treatment Slush Fund Scandal | DRCNet Temporarily Suspending Our Web-Based Write-to-Congress Service Due to Funding Shortfalls -- Your Help Can Bring It Back -- Keep Contacting Congress in the Meantime | Perry Fund Accepting Applications for 2003-2004 and 2004-2005 School Years, Providing Scholarships for Students Losing Aid Because of Drug Convictions | The Reformer's Calendar

This issue -- main page
This issue -- single-file printer version
Drug War Chronicle -- main page
Chronicle archives
Out from the Shadows HEA Drug Provision Drug War Chronicle Perry Fund DRCNet en EspaŮol Speakeasy Blogs About Us Home
Why Legalization? NJ Racial Profiling Archive Subscribe Donate DRCNet em PortuguÍs Latest News Drug Library Search
special friends links: SSDP - Flex Your Rights - IAL - Drug War Facts the Drug Reform Coordination Network (DRCNet)
1623 Connecticut Ave., NW, 3rd Floor, Washington DC 20009 Phone (202) 293-8340 Fax (202) 293-8344 [email protected]