CHANGING MINDS, LAWS & LIVES CAMPAIGN

About DRCNetStop the Drug War (DRCNet) is an international organization working for an end to drug prohibition worldwide and for interim policy reform in US drug laws and criminal justice system. Read more about DRCNet.

Make a Donation

Want to stop the drug war? One way to help is to make a generous donation -- member support makes up a critical portion of our budget, and we can't do it without you!

some organizations DRCNet played a role in starting:


en Españolem Português

Drug War Chronicle - world’s leading drug policy newsletter

Chronicle Book Review: "Dying to Get High: Marijuana as Medicine," by Wendy Chapkis and Richard J. Webb (2008, NYU Press, 244 pp., $22.00 PB)

Click here to order this book today!

Phillip S. Smith, Writer/Editor

http://stopthedrugwar.org/files/chapkis.gif
In "Dying to Get High," sociologists Wendy Chapkis and Richard Webb have written a sympathetic yet academically rigorous account of the contemporary controversies surrounding medical marijuana. They trace the use of marijuana as medicine in the US, its decline as a medicine in the early 20th Century, its removal from the pharmacopeia in 1941 (just four years after it was banned by federal law), the continuing blockage of research into its medical benefits by ideologically-driven federal authorities, and the renaissance of medical marijuana knowledge today, much of it derived from -- gasp! -- patients, not doctors or researchers.

As sociologists, Chapkis and Webb have a keen eye for the broader social, cultural, and political forces surrounding the issue of medical marijuana, from the rise of the pharmaceutical and medical establishments to the "culture war" contempt for marijuana and users among many Americans. But as much as middle America may disdain pot-smoking hippies, it seems that it is marijuana's location on the wrong side of the modern scientific and pharmaceutical discourse that most hinders its acceptance as a medicine.

Pot is a plant, not a pill. It is an herbal medication, not a chemical compound. It is a "crude plant material," not a "pure drug." All of this, Chapkis and Webb suggest, make it difficult indeed for the medical and scientific establishment to wrap its head around medical marijuana. And when scientific bias is coupled with cultural disdain and fear of widespread "abuse," that the federal government remains resistant to medical marijuana is hardly a surprise.

Chapkis and Webb deliver a resounding, well-reasoned indictment of the political and (pseudo) scientific opposition to medical marijuana, and their succinct discussion of the issues surrounding the controversy is worth the price of admission.

http://stopthedrugwar.org/files/wammposter.jpg
But "Dying to Get High" is also an in-depth portrait of one of the country's most well-known medical marijuana collectives, the Wo/Men's Access to Medical Marijuana (WAMM) collective in Santa Cruz, California, and it is here that the authors are really breaking new ground. They go from the big-picture sociology of medical marijuana in the past century to narrowly focus on ethnography of a patient collective, describing in loving detail the inner workings, dynamics, and tensions of a group with charismatic leadership -- Mike and Valerie Corral -- more than 200 seriously ill patients, and the specter of the DEA always looming.

Their account of the emergence and permanence of WAMM is both moving and enlightening. Rooted in the fertile soil of Santa Cruz, already well-tilled by previous social movements such as feminism, gay rights, and AIDS activism, WAMM may only have been possible in a place that friendly to radical movements and that familiar with activism around issues of medical care and social justice. Chapkis and Webb chart its formation, its growth, its conflicts and problems, and the humanity of its suffering members.

They also tell the story of the 2002 DEA raid on the WAMM garden and its devastating impact on members. But that raid and its aftermath were not just a blow to the sick and dying, they were a call to arms, impelling WAMM into ever more overtly political action to protect itself and the broader movement.

More broadly, Chapkis and Webb do a great service by dissecting WAMM, looking at how it works, how it handles dysfunction, and how it provides a service far beyond mere medical marijuana to its members. WAMM is perhaps the model medical marijuana collective, and it has many lessons to offer the interested reader.

Would a WAMM-style collective work elsewhere? Chapkis and Webb emphasize the importance of the cultural and political backdrop in Santa Cruz in making WAMM possible, but I think the very emergence of WAMM as a successful collective makes the possibility of similar collectives coming into being elsewhere all the more likely. After all, even California as a whole is not as radicalized as Santa Cruz or San Francisco, but similar collectives are popping up in Santa Rosa and the San Fernando Valley, among other places.

In any case, Chapkis and Webb provide plenty to chew on, for those who want to pick up some historical knowledge and debating points, for those interested in the genesis of the contemporary marijuana movement, and for those who are pondering the viability of similarly radical approaches to health and self-organizing.

Click here to order this book today!

Drug War Issues Medical Marijuana
Politics & Advocacy Organizations

Please share your story

First let me say that my heart goes out to you for all the challenges you have had to meet. Having shingles by itself is enough to lay one low (I speak from experience!). To have shingles compounding the symptoms and difficulties of MS . . . well, I just cannot imaging how you cope. Your strength is amazing.

My friend, I want to encourage you to please, please, please put this story that you have shared with us in this forum into letters to your two Senators, and Congressional representative. Also, to you state senator and assembly member. Hearing this story directly from you will make a huge difference in shifting their consciousness, and ultimately changing the laws of this country.

I have told my own story to my representatives, and I encourage everyone reading this to do the same. Please also write 'letters to the editors,' whenever you see an appropriate story in newspaper and magazines about pot busts, or the awfulness of cannabis, etc, combating claims and voicing your skepticism about the drug war. I was surprised that as soon as I did this in my local newspaper, someone else wrote expressing the same sentiments on the next story. Please encourage all your like minded friends to do so as well.

Our rational point of view has been suppressed in the mainstream media, but this is changing. And the change will accelerate as more and more of us make our voices heard -- we must all speak up until this ridiculous and mean-spirited so called war on drugs is finally ended.

As I have previously pointed

As I have previously pointed out,
"It's not about the drug. It's about money and power."
The fact that it is medicinally helpful is irrelevant to those who oppose its use. So sad...

Altering consciousness and reality.

While I can understand your position vis a vis cannabis and recreation, I would just like to put this thought out for your consideration: while it is true, as you say, that the main impetus behind recreational use of cannabis is the alteration of consciousness, Reality can never be altered. Reality is what is true, changeless, solid, unmodifiable. If it were not all of that, it would simple not be Reality.

Consciousness, on the other hand, is always being altered. Its very nature is change. It is constantly effected and altered by our experience, memory, family, culture, perceptions, programs we watch, food we eat, language, mood, company, etc. So, if you feel there is some kind of unaltered consciousness, that is 'true' consciousness, I wonder where in fact you find it?

I do not, in any way, mean to belittle your experience. You say that you work in the mental health field, with drug addicts and abusers, who use their drugs to alter consciousness, and you suggest that they came to the state they were in because they used cannabis first. That they used cannabis first may be so, and I suspect someone who works with alcoholics on a day to day basis, might also believe that beer should be made illegal.

I do suggest, however, that we are talking about a very small percentage of the population that finds life so painful, and are so bereft of strategies for dealing with that pain, that they resort to drugs to numb themselves. And I suspect that someone in such a state would try all the available options: cigarettes, coffee, alcohol, cannabis, television, sex, drugs, etc, in order to lessen the pain.

But, to make something criminal for the whole population, based on the sad experiences of the few, that is where the problem arises. Yes, make smoking illegal in public places, for second hand tobacco smoke has been known to kill. Make drinking on public streets illegal, because public drinking often leads to violence. Make impaired driving a crime, for two and a half tons of out of control automobile is deadly. Smoking cannabis in your own home, harming no other, or growing a plant, harming no other, is not a criminal act -- though it has been deemed such by our arcane and thoughtless laws.

Legalize, regulate, educate. It worked with alcohol, with tobacco, it will work with cannabis and drugs. Driving the consumption and distribution of these substances into an underworld of crime and gangs, neither addresses the situation effectively, nor protects the rights of a free people.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <i> <blockquote> <p> <address> <pre> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may post code using <code>...</code> (generic) or <?php ... ?> (highlighted PHP) tags.
  • Web and e-mail addresses are automatically converted into links.
More information about formatting options