Warrantless Cell Phone Tracking Being Challenged in Courts, Senate [FEATURE]

special to Drug War Chronicle by investigative journalist Clarence Walker, cwalkerinvestigate@gmail.com

In the wake of the US Supreme Court's January decision in United States v. Jones, in which the high court forbade the warrantless use of GPS tracking devices to surveil people's movements, law enforcement and the Obama administration are scrambling -- not to find ways to comply with the spirit of the ruling, but to find ways around it.

Police in many states have switched tactics by obtaining mobile data to zero in on someone's prior movement and by tracking them through their cell phones, usually without a warrant. Whenever a cell phone is used, it "pings" an electronic signal to the nearest cell phone tower, allowing law enforcement to use the cell phone to find or track people. And cell phones containing GPS devices, which are increasingly common, "ping" constantly.

In April, the  American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) released an extensive study of state, federal, and local law enforcement's surveillance practices that illustrate how police track citizens through their cell phones. The findings were staggering. Warrantless cell phone tracking "has become a powerful and widely used surveillance tool for police officials, with hundreds of departments, large and small, often using it aggressively with little or no court oversight," the report found.

After poring over 5,500 pages of records in responses from over 200 local law enforcement agencies, the ACLU researchers reported that "only a tiny minority" -- 10 agencies total -- had obtained a warrant before tracking someone through his or her cell phone.

"What we have learned is disturbing," said ACLU staff attorney Catherine Crump, who helped file public information requests with some 385 law enforcement agencies. "The government should have to get a warrant before tracking a cell phone. Instead, what we found was that the cops track people with no supervision, or in some cases, mostly drug cases, the cop will go to court and only show that it would be relevant to an investigation, which is a lower standard."

The ACLU is calling for law enforcement agencies to desist from using cell phone tracking without a warrant, and is calling on state and federal lawmakers to pass legislation requiring a warrant before police use location tracking in non-emergency situations.

A bill to address the problem is pending in Congress. Senate Bill 1212, the Geolocation Privacy and Surveillance (GPS) Act, is sponsored in the Senate by Senators Ron Wyden (D-OR) and Mark Kirk (R-IL). Companion legislation in the House, House Resolution 2168, is sponsored by Reps. Jason Chaffetz (R-UT), Peter Welch (D-VT) and Jim Sensenbrenner (R-WI.). The bills would require law enforcement agents to obtain a warrant in order to access location information.

Another Senate effort, Judiciary Committee chair Senator Patrick Leahy's (D-VT) Electronic Communications Privacy Act Amendments Act, Senate Bill 2011, offers a partial repair of the problem. It includes a warrant requirement for real-time tracking, but not for historical location information.

The Obama administration disagrees that any action is needed. At a State of the Mobile Net conference held in May, Justice Department Deputy Assistant Attorney Jason Weinstein argued, "[t]he need for such warrantless cell phone tracking is important so it won't cripple the government and law enforcement."

The administration's lawyers insist that when a person turns on a cell phone, the information from the phone is transmitted through a third-party, such as the wireless carrier, and the user thus has no "expectation of privacy."

Warrantless cell phone tracking "should be illegal," said Washington, DC, appellate attorney Stephan Leckar, who successfully represented DC nightclub owner Antoine Jones in the case cited above.

In that case, the Supreme Court reversed Jones' conviction and sentence of life without parole in a cocaine trafficking case after they found substantial evidence that the FBI placed a GPS device on Jones vehicle for 28 days without a search warrant. When police monitored Jones vehicle without a warrant, the court said, "This violated his Fourth Amendment right against unreasonable search and seizure."

According to Leckar, the "third-party" doctrine is a means for law enforcement to get around the Fourth Amendment. "As the law reads," he said, the 'third-party' doctrine doesn't violate the Fourth Amendment. To change this, people will have to petition Congress to change that doctrine."

http://stopthedrugwar.org/files/judge-lynn-hughes.jpg
Judge Lynn Hughes
While privacy advocates like the ACLU's Crump argue that cell phone users should get the same protections against warrantless tracking as people subjected to GPS devices being surreptitiously placed on their vehicles, the Justice Department disagrees.

"There is no trespass or physical intrusion on a citizen's cell phone when the government obtains historical cell-site records from a provider," Justice Department attorneys argued in a brief in an appeals court case in February, adding that cell phone data are not as precise as GPS tracking data.

Most, but not all, recent state and federal court decisions in major drug cases have upheld the right of police to either track cell phones or search them for evidence in an investigation. In March, the US 7th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a warrantless search of a cell phone by Indiana police, a phone belonging to a  meth dealer identified as Abel Flores Lopez. Flores was given ten years in federal prison. His co-defendant Alberto Santana Cabrera received the toughest punishment. Santana got 75 years after failing to assist the government with valuable information on other drug dealers.

But federal judicial opinion isn't unanimous. Last year, in a blistering one-page ruling, US District Court Judge Lynn Hughes of the Southern District of Texas in Houston declared "that the law allowing the government to obtain cell phone records without a warrant is unconstitutional."

In that case, federal prosecutors had subpoenaed MetroPCS and T-Mobile to hand over sixty days of cell phone location data belonging to drug suspects. "The records would show the date, time, called number, and location of the telephone when the call was made," Hughes noted.

As the law now stands, cell phone customers who value their privacy are at the mercy of law enforcement and their wireless service providers. And the wireless service providers are all too happy to work with law enforcement voluntarily, and turn a tidy profit doing it.

Our favorite carriers, including AT&T, Verizon, T-Mobile and Sprint, are in on the action by selling information to police about a person's whereabouts, including the sale of private text messages and cell tower data, which pinpoint the location where someone is using a cell, the New York Times reported in March. Some companies are marketing surveillance fees to law enforcement to spy on targets even though wireless carriers declare that they don't sell their customers' information to police.

The Times found that T-Mobile charges law enforcement $150 per-hour for cell phone data that shows the approximate location of the tower that a cell phone "pings" off of when the user makes a call. It found that Alltel provides a faxed listing of an electronic "Tower Dump" for specific times and dates. The listing is "no charge," but the company charges a flat rate of $500 for those searches.

Verizon Wireless, on the other hand, charges  $30-$60 for 15 minutes' worth of tower data, while AT&T charges $75 hourly (a minimum of two to four hours per tower) for a Cell Tower Dump or Cell Site Usage Report. Cell Site Usage also includes subscriber information for the location, date and time when a phone was used.

The Times also found that Sprint once billed the Raleigh, North Carolina, Police Department at a "reduced rate" of $50 for an historic tower search and added $30 more for a search of "L-Site GPS pings," while the ACLU reported that Sprint had billed the Phoenix Police Department $460 for the GPS "pings" over a two-day period in 2009.

"The bottom line is that our mobile phone companies should be working for us, their customers, not the police, says Nicole Ozer, an ACLU staff attorney.

Not only are the wireless providers profiting from your privacy by working with the police, they are lobbying to be able to continue to do so. Even as the debate rages over warrantless cell phone tracking, cell carriers are geared up to oppose legislation that would force the companies to publicly report the number of times their employees provide cell phone location information to police and federal agents.

Sen. Al Franken
One important proposal is California Senate Bill 1434, introduced by Sen. Mark Leno (D-San Francisco), which would prohibit carriers from revealing data to police without a warrant. Wireless providers are joining together to fight it.

"These reporting mandates would unduly prevent us from insuring the public's safety and saving lives," AT&T, Sprint, and T-Mobile said in a joint statement.

The battle continues. Motivated by the ACLU research and news reports on the controversy surrounding  warrantless cell phone tracking, US Senator Al Franken (D-Minnesota) recently convened a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing to gather support for the GPS Act. At the hearing, Franken unveiled a letter he had written to Attorney General Holder seeking information on Justice Department cell phone tracking activity, what the department's stance on the standard for requests for historical location data (cell sites, GPS data), and whether the department had changed its practices in the light of the Jones decision.

He is still awaiting a response from Justice.

On the legal front, with state and federal courts split in their decisions on whether warrantless phone tracking violates the Fourth Amendment, the tens of millions of Americans who use cell phones and smart phones will have to wait for the Supreme Court to be the final arbiter. In the meantime, they could just be tracking you -- warrant or not.

Permission to Reprint: This article is licensed under a modified Creative Commons Attribution license.
Looking for the easiest way to join the anti-drug war movement? You've found it!

Counter-surveillance will be big business in the future

With all these scanners, trackers, detectors being used by big business and law enforcement, somebody who designs and markets some scramblers for the general public will make mega bucks.

lol

I am sure the highest bidder will win, its the American way. Bought and paid for politicians.

www.Privacy-Nerds.tk

We the people, have no rights

We the people, have no rights anymore. These big corporations are so greedy they will do anything for a dollar and screw the people supporting them. We are becoming prisoners of our own country. The United States Government has become the world police including this country. They are more concerned about wars and prisons than education and healthcare. If their not trying to f-ck us in our wallet, then they are f--king us in jail !! This country needs to change or we are in serious trouble. It really bothers me to think about what my 3yr old daughter will have to deal with when she's 40. I'll be surprised if she still wants to live in this country.

warrantless cell phone tracking

Thank you for this article there is news in here that I haven't seen elsewhere.  I didn't know major carriers were making $ off of us by collaborating with law enforcement.

One solution is to live without a cell phone.  Not trying to be a smart-aleck here.  I hate the things I don't want people to be able to conveniently interrupt me in my day let alone track where I am or what I'm doing. 

I really appreciate jason4244's comments especially about the world his kid will grow up in.  I think about the world I grew up in.  When I was young you didn't have to pass through metal detectors at the courthouse, police dept. or school.  Now you do.  There's a lot more authority out there trying to get each and every one of us to submit.  Harder & harder to just live your life & be left alone.

Warantless cell phone spy

As far as i know, a House subcommittee considered a bill that would address this threat to privacy by requiring a warrant for geolocational surveillance, regardless of the method used. Is it effective enough?

Privacy Tool

 

There are solutions, but until we get proper legislation making app developers, have you op in instead of opting out, you will never know what you have downloaded to your mobile device. 

Using a SilentPocket™ allows you to take control of your own privacy when it comes to Smartphone tracking. MIAmobi™ addresses this issue and many more problems associated with mobile devices. With over 500,000 mobile app developed for smartphones, many of which are stealth and are eavesdropping on your every move. Some are capable of turning on functions on your phone like your mic, camera, GPS, address book and more, even when it has been turned off. There is only one way to stop this if you really want to know for sure that you have control of your mobile device is to block all forms of wifi coming in or going out. Get informed at MIA-mobi.com

MIAmobi also provides a tool to help not only teens but everyone from being distracted by cell phones. One of these tools is the SilentPocket. If we start getting people to use the MIAmobi SilentPocket™ “It will save lives” Out site out of mind. Helps prevents texting and driving. Voicemail rings, beeps, blings or vibes will not be heard. Voicemail, Texts and email will be received once the device is taken out of the SilentPocket.  Learn more at  MIA-mobi

Thanks for the link!

Thanks for the link! I never heard of it. It just really bothers me that the big phone companies rape their customers every month and turn around and screw them at the same time by selling their info. The 2 year contracts should protect the customer more, after all we pay them for a service, and if we didn't, there would be a lot more unemployed people looking for jobs.

I assume if you have both cell data (3 or 4G), and gps off, its  a little more difficult to pinpoint?

Tips

If we start getting people to use the MIAmobi SilentPocket™ “It will save lives” Out site out of mind. Helps prevents texting and driving. Voicemail rings, beeps, blings or vibes will not be heard. Voicemail, Texts and email will be received once the device is taken out of the SilentPocket.

As far as i know about it

As far as i know about it warantless mobile tracking, a House subcommittee considered a bill that would address this threat to privacy by requiring a warrant for geolocational surveillance, regardless of the method used. Is it effective enough?

Elected Officials wouldn't know what (REAL) FREEDOM is...

if it smacked them in the mouth! People talk about how Obamacare will take away our freedom & it makes me sick. Not that I like the healthcare bill, but it's not taking away freedom! All these "Tea Party" people got up in arms over that bull shit. But where were they when Bush signed the Patriot Act? Or when Obama signed NDAA 6 months ago? Now those 2 bills took away our freedom. Those bills gave helped make the U.S. a Police State, but only a few have had the balls to speak out on it! And even less people in the media reporting on it... (SIGH) It is bad enough we have had to deal w/ the Prison Industrial Complex & the ignorant, immoral, racist "War on Drugs"! Now we got rogue Police Departments thinking they can do anything they damn well please. Idk? Maybe these cops learned it from watching Season 5 of 'The Wire'? Anywho, until we get more people in Congress & courts, who truly believe in Civil Liberties we are fucked! (I think a good start to ending these problems would be, for members Congress who care about these issues to start a "Civil Liberties Caucus")
John Thomas's picture

Does turning the cell phone

Does turning the cell phone off help?  Or removing the chip?

No More Privacy Ever Again

Communications companies, the government and data trawlers are hell bent on getting us to the point where everything we do is instantly visible under the guise of law enforcement but mostly because marketers can make trillions. Its our privacy and our data they are milking... the least they can do for violating our privacy is cut us a check.

mobile tracking

Delacon’s Phone Lead Alert lets you track both the web source of a lead and the way in which keywords used in internet searches convert into phone enquiries.
 

tied dark way in heart:This square brigade's jxhlzev

Nike san francisco 49ers jersey Cheap if is surplus 20th, boats and ships up, many Mo La Zu's warriors are also entered ocean by book, or are drawn near ocean by the star monster in sea, the loss is it may be said huge matchless, a lot too big. This result lets Mo La Zu gets desire to cry to has no tears generally, have never thought NCAA Hats Soon allly living to work properly to all constitute, understand one different troops of turning over, constituting at the same time mutually, however mostly the oneself world constitute his/her own 1 brigade, this is also the different world cause, and the nothing affair was already after many wholesale nashville predators jerseys way:Eldest brother, you have already conquered I thoroughly. The square green Lan after seeking the quasi- position suddenly gets into kid Xie's body, immediately after way:Even if have already also conquered to want. The over square green Lan started delivering dint, kid Xie drive square green Lan cheap nike jerseys of years to just re- return mountain, . Cover with inside the joss-stick palace, there has been several fairy houses separately sitting properly in the both ends at this time, the left side is the person of Xuan door, the right side is a Buddhism and spreads to fix of person, at this time, greatly chicago bulls Hats away to is very difficult to be once having got, so can meaningless accolade, so as to realize an oneself, besides this is regarded as what bother, don't feel at all, small Japans all once polished off, only a little crafty pimp has what relation. Stroll about, returned to in the hotel, leave of is Tha Alumni Snapbacks army in, now but connect free of the rays of star was also called to come over to guard, really is not pull clansmen Be getting tooer many, killing the greater half can also appear greater half again, this battle how go to and beat ah, really is that the hard nut to crack is beyond doubt./Www.Qb 5, oakley radar lenses have much of confidence, can Meng strong facial expression but seem to be dignified, the square green Lan notices this to public say:So, ignore game who??Who win, this money is used to how is tonight dinner party?Is public to loudly shout bravo, and make through this , the Meng strong facial Last Kings Snapback Hats look for other the establishments ownly practice moral teachings of ground, aftertime every month of beginning an and the 15th, last officer island listen to 3 of officer's house turn absolute being super strong speak way, and according to practicing moral teachings state to receive a miracle drug Cheap Snapbacks australia all alone, kneel at work properly a treasure way gentleman is before the body.3 people seeing side or delighted, or envy, or envy. Lao Tze the full face is delighted, wish, not the Kui is me three pure head Tu, the natural intelligence is extraordinary, the nature is also good, the disposition is Minnesota Twins jerseys china that sort that bead son thinks will cover with flower petal to burn fly ash, anti- poured to arouse a burst of of violent explosion. Covering with of air flower petal good a B wood thunder bead.Drive the sun the true fire set off, tens of thousands thunder beads set off together and even if work Supreme Snapback Hats secretary BEgreen elder brother Lan, it is thus clear that it is one how fanatical of make track for a star clan, also no wonder that she will at the situation like this like this rude in behavior and unexpectedly even forgot the works of duty, public not from of the wry smile shake head. The square 40 OZ NY Stars Snapback Hats hurriedly shout a way:Husband, do not, this wild countryside the indisposition of the wild Ling!Do not urgently, for man from have a way.Finish saying, the square green Lan changes on opening widely a bed, pillow, sheet of bed what of the all are good enough, rolled in the bed together with two Wholesale Amakipkip Hats history, at that time can be probably, west week east week etc., there is also Shang Dynasty for Xia Dynasty, these things for leaving Be getting more rarely seen, had some is obviously lost, the battle fire is heartless. See more much, also clear a lot of, as for China absolute being state why will mlb Rays jerseys for women latter is immediately jubilant of will it income space ring in, then satisfiedly stand down a set. Because had without the Chou the don't shout three* ten thousand, also have higher of of raise Cuo, for clapping of have nine star classes work properly machine Qian quality of eight star class the YSL Snapback Hats away from him. She ever because own destiny flowed through numerous tearses, but after sheding tears still kept strongly facing a life, believed that square green's in the mind packs oneself, exactly she wanted to make a phone call for square green on this day, is it her birthday to want to suggest mlb Twins jerseys for kids E F almond Huang Qi launch before body and evolve ten thousand yellow lotuses and protect all over the body, the sword once annoys place, and numerous lotuses become Ji powder, but once didn't need sword spirit to face the disaster of the body.Another side, soar to the skies with quasi- lift Dou

Granted I am all for people

Granted I am all for people having their privacy...but today a woman's purse was stolen with over $1000 worth of property inside, including her cell phone. Being able to ping her phone would have allowed us to potentially find the suspects, since we requested it immediately upon finding out her phone was in the purse. 

Unfortunately, AT&T felt that this was not an exigent circumstance, and would not do it. Now this woman has to pay even more money by changing locks in her home and potentially her car, in addition to what she will have to pay to replace all of her property.

I think there should be certain situations where we are able to ping phones, especially when there is a victim to a crime and we have the victim's consent. 

I think there should be

I think there should be certain situations where we are able to ping phones, especially when there is a victim to a crime and we have the victim's consent. Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. The Newsroom 2 DVD Box Set UK Vikings Season 1 DVD Box Set UK South Park Seasons 1-15 DVD Box Set UK Battlestar Galactica Seasons 1-4 DVD Boxset Game of Thrones seasons 1-3 DVD Box set

"The records would show the

"The records would show the date, time, called number, and location of the telephone when the call was made," Hughes noted.I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post.Two and a Half Men Seasons 1-10 DVD Box Set Lie to Me Seasons 1-3 DVD Box Set The Tudors Seasons 1-4 DVD Box Set CSI Las Vegas Seasons 1-13 DVD Box Set CSI: NY Seasons 1-9 DVD Box Set How I Met Your Mother Season 8 DVD Box Set

Thanks for this read mate.

Thanks for this read mate. Well, this is my first visit to your blog! But I admire the precious time and effort you put into it, especially into interesting articles you share here. You're truly well informed and very intelligent. You wrote something that people could understand and made the subject intriguing for everyone. I'm saving this for future use. Friends seasons 1-10 DVD Box set | Rules of Engagement Seasons 1-5 DVD Box set | The Walking Dead seasons 1-3 DVD Box set | Supernatural Seasons 1-8 DVD Box set | Futurama Seasons 1-5 DVD Box set

I enjoyed reading your

I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work. The post in this site is very cool and also interesting. I had read the entire blog and I came to know many things which I don’t know before. I am sure that the visitors who visit this site will also be enjoying reading the posts. Family guy seasons 1-11 DVD Box set | Dexter Seasons 1-8 DVD Box set | Sons of Anarchy Seasons 1-5 DVD Box set | True Blood Seasons 1-6 dvd box set | Cold Case seasons 1-7 dvd box set

especially when there is a

especially when there is a victim to a crime and we have the victim's consent. Great blog article about this topic, I have been lately in your blog once or twice now. I Two and a Half Men Seasons 1-10 DVD Box Set Lie to Me Seasons 1-3 DVD Box Set The Tudors Seasons 1-4 DVD Box Set CSI Las Vegas Seasons 1-13 DVD Box Set CSI: NY Seasons 1-9 DVD Box Set How I Met Your Mother Season 8 DVD Box Set

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <i> <blockquote> <p> <address> <pre> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <br> <object> <param> <embed> <b>

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Drug War Issues

Criminal JusticeAsset Forfeiture, Collateral Sanctions (College Aid, Drug Taxes, Housing, Welfare), Court Rulings, Drug Courts, Due Process, Felony Disenfranchisement, Incarceration, Policing (2011 Drug War Killings, 2012 Drug War Killings, 2013 Drug War Killings, 2014 Drug War Killings, Arrests, Eradication, Informants, Interdiction, Lowest Priority Policies, Police Corruption, Police Raids, Profiling, Search and Seizure, SWAT/Paramilitarization, Task Forces, Undercover Work), Probation or Parole, Prosecution, Reentry/Rehabilitation, Sentencing (Alternatives to Incarceration, Clemency and Pardon, Crack/Powder Cocaine Disparity, Death Penalty, Decriminalization, Defelonization, Drug Free Zones, Mandatory Minimums, Rockefeller Drug Laws, Sentencing Guidelines)CultureArt, Celebrities, Counter-Culture, Music, Poetry/Literature, Television, TheaterDrug UseParaphernalia, ViolenceIntersecting IssuesCollateral Sanctions (College Aid, Drug Taxes, Housing, Welfare), Violence, Border, Budgets/Taxes/Economics, Business, Civil Rights, Driving, Economics, Education (College Aid), Employment, Environment, Families, Free Speech, Gun Policy, Human Rights, Immigration, Militarization, Money Laundering, Pregnancy, Privacy (Search and Seizure, Drug Testing), Race, Religion, Science, Sports, Women's IssuesMarijuana PolicyGateway Theory, Hemp, Marijuana -- Personal Use, Marijuana Industry, Medical MarijuanaMedicineMedical Marijuana, Science of Drugs, Under-treatment of PainPublic HealthAddiction, Addiction Treatment (Science of Drugs), Drug Education, Drug Prevention, Drug-Related AIDS/HIV or Hepatitis C, Harm Reduction (Methadone & Other Opiate Maintenance, Needle Exchange, Overdose Prevention, Safe Injection Sites)Source and Transit CountriesAndean Drug War, Coca, Hashish, Mexican Drug War, Opium ProductionSpecific DrugsAlcohol, Ayahuasca, Cocaine (Crack Cocaine), Ecstasy, Heroin, Ibogaine, ketamine, Khat, Marijuana (Gateway Theory, Marijuana -- Personal Use, Medical Marijuana, Hashish), Methamphetamine, New Synthetic Drugs (Synthetic Cannabinoids, Synthetic Stimulants), Nicotine, Prescription Opiates (Fentanyl, Oxycontin), Psychedelics (LSD, Mescaline, Peyote, Salvia Divinorum)YouthGrade School, Post-Secondary School, Raves, Secondary School