Editorial: Reasonable Doubt Routinely 4/4/03

Drug War Chronicle, recent top items


recent blog posts "In the Trenches" activist feed


David Borden, Executive Director, [email protected], 4/4/03

Several years ago, a friend and DRCNet supporter commented to me that the information we provided him in his e-mail was always bad news, important but depressing. A couple of years later, he told me the news in DRCNet wasn't all bad anymore; some of the news was actually good.

This past week brought some very good news, though still incomplete, the repudiation by Texas officials of the infamous Tulia incarcerations -- which I described as the "Tulia Lynchings" in a previous editorial -- and the likelihood that all of the Tulia convictions will be vacated and the remaining defendants released and not re-tried.

Jeff Blackburn, an attorney who labored effortlessly for years on behalf of the Tulia victims, discussed the larger problems in the criminal justice system of which Tulia was just one famous illustration, and some legal reforms that he and other advocates are pressing for in Texas, including a bill actually passed last year that requires that testimony given by informants be corroborated. Blackburn doesn't feel this goes far enough, however; he thinks the testimony of police officers should have to be corroborated too.

On the face of it, some might consider this extreme and reflective of an "anti-police" viewpoint. But it is neither. One need not believe that all cops lie, nor even that most lie, to recognize that perjury and other misconduct by police officers is a significant problem -- this weekly newsletter runs a "corrupt cop" story every issue, and we never have trouble finding one -- and this concern is not limited to "radicals" or defense attorneys.

Dr. Joseph McNamara, for example, former police chief in Kansas City and San Jose, early in his career a beat cop in New York City under Commissioner Patrick Murphy and now a fellow at the conservative Hoover Institution at Stanford University and no enemy of police, has described the problem eloquently. At the 1995 conference of the Drug Policy Foundation in Santa Monica, he ridiculed the obvious fabrications presented in courts routinely by police officers in drug cases, saying, "it boggles the mind, how many defendants do give consent and get searched when they have drugs on them, and say 'Sure, officer, open my trunk.'" McNamara and others have described the term "testi-lying," a well known phrase in modern drug war policing.

Even if police perjury were not half as prevalent as McNamara has described, the phenomenon would still present a fundamental hindrance to the reliability of police testimony in trials for the purpose of obtaining criminal convictions. Our system of justice requires defendants be deemed guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, if they are to be convicted. Reasonable doubt doesn't mean one individual's word against another's, nor even a probability of guilt in the opinion of the juror. Reasonable doubt means the evidence is so strong that there is extremely little probability of innocence. Logically, the uncorroborated testimony of an individual cannot be considered to be beyond reasonable doubt, if the class to which that individual belongs has a record of unreliability in testimony -- even if most members of that class are reliable.

This is not an extreme statement or an anti-police statement; it is an objective statistical conclusion as to what it takes in today's society and criminal justice system to be reasonably certain the person sent to prison or jail is actually guilty. This is not a comfortable conclusion; it is a conclusion that would fundamentally shake the foundations of drug war policing if implemented to its logical conclusion. But it is an accurate line of reasoning, for which I've never heard a solid argument in opposition.

Simply, if we respect the principle of requiring guilt beyond a reasonable doubt to secure a conviction, and if we are lawful and obey the rules which mandate that standard, then Blackburn's proposed policy should be fully implemented, new law or not. The fact that this has not already been done shows that judges and jurors en masse have not respected that principle. It is tragic that the standards in US criminal justice have deteriorated to such a degree that this is necessary. But that is a reason to reform the policies driving the problem, not to dilute an all-important tenet for protecting the innocent that has stood for centuries.

Hence, Blackburn's proposal may be the only way to restore integrity to the system and to prevent more Tulias -- and the more routine individual injustices -- from recurring again and again.

-- END --
Link to Drug War Facts
Please make a generous donation to support Drug War Chronicle in 2007!          

PERMISSION to reprint or redistribute any or all of the contents of Drug War Chronicle (formerly The Week Online with DRCNet is hereby granted. We ask that any use of these materials include proper credit and, where appropriate, a link to one or more of our web sites. If your publication customarily pays for publication, DRCNet requests checks payable to the organization. If your publication does not pay for materials, you are free to use the materials gratis. In all cases, we request notification for our records, including physical copies where material has appeared in print. Contact: StoptheDrugWar.org: the Drug Reform Coordination Network, P.O. Box 18402, Washington, DC 20036, (202) 293-8340 (voice), (202) 293-8344 (fax), e-mail [email protected]. Thank you.

Articles of a purely educational nature in Drug War Chronicle appear courtesy of the DRCNet Foundation, unless otherwise noted.

Issue #281, 4/4/03 Week Online Fundraising Update | Editorial: Reasonable Doubt Routinely | Victory in Tulia! | Rosenthal Asks for New Trial, Cites Juror Violations | Drug Czar Gives Up on Drugs and Terror Ad Campaign, Also Cancels Studies to Track Ads' Effectiveness | Drug Czar Sends Flunkies to Try to Stop Columbia, Missouri, Marijuana Initiative | DRCNet Interview: Marco Cappato, Member of European Parliament | Newsbrief: Reform Rumblings Begin in Brazil, While Commands Create Chaos | Newsbrief: Post-Assassination Serbian Crackdown Creates Drug Panic | Newsbrief: Jamaican Official Promises Ganja Decrim Bill Soon | Newsbrief: Belgian Marijuana Decriminalization Passes Final Hurdle | Newsbrief: Midwest Meth Madness -- Indiana | Newsbrief: Midwest Meth Madness -- Iowa and Illinois | Newsbrief: This Week's Corrupt Cop Story | Web Scan: New HR95, JAPHA on Syringe Sales, Reason, Mama Coca, OAS | Clinical Cannabis Conference CDs Available | Job Listings: Drug Policy Forum of Massachusetts and Albuquerque Health Care for the Homeless | The Reformer's Calendar

This issue -- main page
This issue -- single-file printer version
Drug War Chronicle -- main page
Chronicle archives
Out from the Shadows HEA Drug Provision Drug War Chronicle Perry Fund DRCNet en EspaŮol Speakeasy Blogs About Us Home
Why Legalization? NJ Racial Profiling Archive Subscribe Donate DRCNet em PortuguÍs Latest News Drug Library Search
special friends links: SSDP - Flex Your Rights - IAL - Drug War Facts

StoptheDrugWar.org: the Drug Reform Coordination Network (DRCNet)
1623 Connecticut Ave., NW, 3rd Floor, Washington DC 20009 Phone (202) 293-8340 Fax (202) 293-8344 [email protected]