Narco
News
First
Amendment
Trial
Begins,
Electronic
Frontier
Foundation
Files
Amicus
Brief
7/20/01
The Drug War on Trial case has its first
hearing today, Friday, July 20th, at the New York Supreme Court in Manhattan.
The hearing is open to the press and public, and will take place at 71
Thomas Street (corner of West Broadway, across from the Odeon Cafeteria,
near the Chambers St. Station on the 1,2,3 and 9 trains), Courtroom #205,
Justice Paula Omansky presiding. The hearing begins at 9:30am, and
will be followed by a Narco News press conference.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF),
a leading organization defending first amendment rights in the cyber-age,
filed an amicus brief in support of the Narco News Bulletin's right to
publish. A complete copy of the brief is available at http://www.narconews.com/effamicus.html
online, as well as other briefs in the case through the Narco News home
page. Some excerpts from EFF's memorandum follow:
-
"The new independent journalists of the Internet,
as personified by Al Giordano, play a crucial role in preserving the democratic
aspirations of First Amendment protection. The role of such journalists
is especially salient as mainstream media is increasingly in the hands
of fewer and fewer large corporations."
-
"The application of New York substantive law
to claims alleging libel for statements made on a foreign website where
the great majority of the alleged harm occurred in a foreign jurisdiction
will encourage explicit forum shopping by plaintiffs. Independent,
online publishers will be less willing to partake in spirited investigative
journalism... The excessive burden placed upon independent, Internet-based
journalists in defending themselves in distant fora chills online journalistic
activity, implicating online First Amendment rights that are of central
concern to the Electronic Frontier Foundation."
-
"Independent, Internet journalism embodies
the democratic vision of the 'freedom of the press' clause of the First
Amendment. Journalists like Al Giordano are able to post their investigative
efforts and the efforts of others via the Internet to the entire world,
with incredibly low production and distribution costs. Given that
mainstream media is increasingly in the hands of fewer and fewer corporations,
the Internet is a crucial outlet for independent media projects such as
Narconews.com. The Supreme Court notably remarked the vital importance
of an independent press in a time of corporate and government conglomeration
in Branzburg v. Hayes, 92 S.Ct. 2646 (1972): 'As private and public aggregations
of power burgeon in size and the pressures for conformity necessarily mount,
there is obviously a continuing need for an independent press to disseminate
a robust variety of information and opinion through reportage, investigation,
and criticism, if we are to preserve our constitutional tradition of maximizing
freedom of choice by encouraging diversity of expression.'"
-
"Banamex's hopes for a 'second chance' to
litigate this dispute are explicit in this case. After a lengthy
criminal libel trial lasting more than two years, a Mexican judge ruled
that Banamex had not been libeled by the Mexican Newspaper Por Esto! which
conducted the investigation republished by Narconews.com. This decision
was upheld on appeal in Mexico in May of last year, and a third attempt
to press criminal charges in Mexico was thrown out of court."
-
"A finding of jurisdiction would be unconstitutional
under the First Amendment given the harm that will ensue to online publishers
such as Mr. Giordano. As the Internet subjects online journalists
to an increasing number of foreign jurisdictions, the doctrine of forum
non conveniens has taken on an even more important role in protecting online
freedom of the press. Through operating as a 'safeguard' against
suit in distant jurisdictions, forum non conveniens minimizes the burden
that online journalists must endure when the legality of their news stories
is challenged in a court of law. The doctrine of forum non conveniens
as applied to libel cases involving online journalism, and mass media in
general, thus offers a distinct way to protect and bolster the First Amendment
rights of journalists and publishers."
-- END --
Issue #195, 7/20/01
Editorial: Robert Downey's Business | Prescription for Prosecution: Feds Go After Oxy Docs in Southwestern Virginia | BC Marijuana Industry Approaching Critical Mass, DEA Not Happy | Ditchweed Update: DEA Numbers | Narco News First Amendment Trial Begins, Electronic Frontier Foundation Files Amicus Brief | Media Scan: Columbia Journalism Review on Cincinnati, Arianna Huffington on Colombia | For Sale: Merchandise and Services to Benefit the Cause | HEA Campaign Gets Media: Student Victim Cases Still Needed | Urgent Action Alerts: Colombia, HEA, Mandatory Minimums, Medical Marijuana, John Walters | The Reformer's Calendar
|
This issue -- main page
This issue -- single-file printer version
Drug War Chronicle -- main page
Chronicle archives
|
PERMISSION to reprint or
redistribute any or all of the contents of Drug War Chronicle (formerly The Week Online with DRCNet is hereby
granted. We ask that any use of these materials include proper credit and,
where appropriate, a link to one or more of our web sites. If your
publication customarily pays for publication, DRCNet requests checks
payable to the organization. If your publication does not pay for
materials, you are free to use the materials gratis. In all cases, we
request notification for our records, including physical copies where
material has appeared in print. Contact: StoptheDrugWar.org: the Drug Reform Coordination Network,
P.O. Box 18402, Washington, DC 20036, (202) 293-8340 (voice), (202)
293-8344 (fax), e-mail [email protected]. Thank
you.
Articles of a purely
educational nature in Drug War Chronicle appear courtesy of the DRCNet
Foundation, unless otherwise noted.
|