Book Review: "Marijuana Legalization: What Everyone Needs to Know"

Marijuana Legalization: What Everyone Needs to Know by Jonathan Caulkins, Angela Hawken, Beau Kilmer, and Mark Kleiman (2012, Oxford University Press, 266 pp., $16.95 PB)

(Note: You can now order "Marijuana Legalization: What Everyone Needs to Know" and support StoptheDrugWar.org at the same time -- click here for details on our current membership offers.)

https://stopthedrugwar.org/files/marijuana-legalization-book-200px.jpg
Marijuana legalization in one form or another will be on the ballot in at least two states -- Colorado and Washington -- this fall, and maybe three, if one or both of the Oregon initiatives currently in the signature validation process actually qualifies. [Editor's Note: One did, Friday night.] Public opinion polls show a populace that is now evenly split on the subject, but with support for it trending rapidly upward in recent years. We could be on the cusp of the biggest changes in how we deal with marijuana since pot prohibition began to emerge in the states a century ago.

So, Marijuana Legalization: What Everyone Needs to Know couldn't be more timely. A collaborative effort by four academic drug policy researchers, this tome is thoughtful, thorough, and balanced as it addresses the wide array of issues and disputes associated with changing pot policy. One can only hope that politicians charged with voting on marijuana policy reform would read it, or at least, that their staffs would do so and offer them up a nicely bullet-pointed précis.

Grappling with the topic of marijuana legalization is a surprisingly complicated affair. Marijuana use is so common, the impacts of marijuana prohibition so pervasive, that to talk about marijuana law reform involves disciplines ranging from botany and biochemistry to medicine and public health and diplomacy and international law, and more. One of the qualities that makes Marijuana Legalization so handy is the way it disaggregates the multi-sided issue into easily digestible, bite-sized chunks. The book is divided into two sections, one on marijuana itself and one on legalization, and subdivided into thematic chapters ("Who Uses Marijuana?" "What are the Risks of Using Marijuana?" "What if Marijuana Were Treated Like Alcohol?"), which in turn are further subdivided into one-to-two page questions and answers.

The answers to the questions are carefully based on the latest academic research and meta-analyses and appear, overall, to be fair representations of the state of knowledge in the fields in question. Sometimes, though, it appears the authors are striving so much for fairness that they risk pulling muscles from bending over backwards.

In the section on the gateway theory, for instance, the authors note that there is a correlation between teen pot use and an increased likelihood of moving on to other drug use, but that a causal relationship is more difficult to determine and that other underlying social, psychological, or physiological risk factors could be at play. Still, they feel compelled to note in language approaching the Rumsfeldian that "the fact that causal connections are not needed to explain the observed correlations does not mean there is no causal connection." Ummm, okay. And the absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Actually, given the decades of efforts to establish the gateway theory, the paucity of evidence to support it is pretty good evidence.

All of the talk about marijuana dependency may grate on the nerves of advocates, some of whom may well qualify as dependent under the clinical criteria. But clearly, like any psychoactive substance, people can grow habituated to pot and it can have deleterious effects. For all the emphasis on marijuana dependency, though, the authors deserve credit for clearly and forthrightly stating that all dependencies are not created equal. It's one thing to be a skin-and-bones crack addict; quite another to smoke pot and be a couch potato every night.

The careful, balanced tone of Marijuana Legalization is something that legalization advocates might want to strive for. This holds doubly true for claims about the impacts of marijuana legalization that might not hold up to scrutiny. For instance, Proposition 19 advocates may have overstated the impact that legalization in California would have on Mexican drug cartels, only to have opponents come back and undercut those claims. Likewise, claims that our prisons are filled with pot-smokers are unsupported by the facts. That anyone is in prison for marijuana is bad enough -- and the authors say 40,000 people are -- but overstating the negatives of even some aspects of prohibition does not aid the cause in the long run.

Similarly, the authors make clear that there are some things we just don't -- and can't -- know. How much would use increase under various legalization schemes? Anyone who tells you they have a definitive answer is blowing smoke, and his credibility should be called into question. We can make educated guesses, but given the lack of laboratory conditions, that's all they are.

When it comes to legalization itself, the authors delineate several versions, from a free market scheme where marijuana is treated like any other commodity to one that that would see marijuana produced and sold with regulations and restrictions like alcohol or tobacco. There is also a medical model and a state monopoly model (similar to what Uruguay is now proposing). Given the "nightmare scenario" -- potential massive decreases in price along with powerful advertising campaigns by vendors leading to massive increase in use and dependency -- of the more open legalization approaches and the political opposition such fears can engender, that state liquor store model looks a little more attractive, even though it runs in the face of current ideological trends about the inability of the state to do anything as well as private enterprise can.

I have to give the authors kudos for one chapter in particular, "What is Known about the Non-Medical Benefits of Marijuana?" In our drug policy discourse in general, marijuana included, the emphasis is almost entirely on the negative results of drug use. That begs the question: If these drugs are so horrible, why does anyone use them in the first place, let alone get strung out on them? Drug use clearly does have positive benefits for users -- otherwise they wouldn't be using them -- and it's refreshing to actually hear some forthright talk about that when it comes to pot.

Marijuana Legalization doesn't advocate for or against legalization. At the very end of the book, each of the authors lays out his or her personal views. But I'm not going to be a spoiler. Read the book and find out for yourself. It's a most handy primer on the diverse and interrelated topics that constitute the universe of marijuana legalization issues, and its structure helps disentangle what can be an overwhelming array of concerns and issues.

Yes, the authors have undoubtedly reached some conclusions that will not be well-received by the drug reform community, but they have done so in a spirit of scholarship and fairness. If you don't like the conclusions they reach, rebut them or deal with them in the same manner. It'll do you and the cause good.

(Note: You can now order "Marijuana Legalization: What Everyone Needs to Know" and support StoptheDrugWar.org at the same time -- click here for details on our current membership offers.)

(The author's have launched a web site associated with the book, http://www.marijuanalegalization.info.)

Permission to Reprint: This article is licensed under a modified Creative Commons Attribution license.
Looking for the easiest way to join the anti-drug war movement? You've found it!

what does a viagra pill do

b9ou http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">find out this here viagra 200mg online 7ymp http://bit.do/eZpii ">viagra without a doctor prescription kh2n viagra alternative https://v.gd/AtnGTE ">viagra gw4g

buying viagra over the counter

lgza http://url.ie/14ch9 ">viagra without a doctor prescription viagra canada online pharmacy knbn http://gul.ly/x8nto ">viagra without a doctor prescription ypni pfizer coupons for viagra https://is.gd/ixm8gy ">Learn More Here v93y

gold viagra

9zon http://cort.as/-L2rr ">Continue Reading viagra equivalent over the counter 6tzn http://url.ie/14ch9 ">right here n0nb mark martin viagra car viagra ci6c

gold viagra

9zon http://cort.as/-L2rr ">Continue Reading viagra equivalent over the counter 6tzn http://url.ie/14ch9 ">right here n0nb mark martin viagra car viagra ci6c

nitric oxide and viagra

4byt viagra rite aid viagra cost ywqe http://cort.as/-L2rr ">viagra vnks what are the side effects of viagra and cialis https://is.gd/ixm8gy ">viagra 1517

nitric oxide and viagra

4byt viagra rite aid viagra cost ywqe http://cort.as/-L2rr ">viagra vnks what are the side effects of viagra and cialis https://is.gd/ixm8gy ">viagra 1517

nitric oxide and viagra

4byt viagra rite aid viagra cost ywqe http://cort.as/-L2rr ">viagra vnks what are the side effects of viagra and cialis https://is.gd/ixm8gy ">viagra 1517

viagra generic teva

jb0c http://gg.gg/ei1hc ">you can try here recommended viagra dosage tebm http://alturl.com/v58am ">this post kfje information about viagra http://url.ie/14ch9 ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com uvk2

walgreen viagra

47e4 http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">viagra viagra nasal spray zcyx viagra without a doctor prescription rjrl viagra results photos https://clck.ru/GzL4B ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com 7ix6

walgreen viagra

47e4 http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">viagra viagra nasal spray zcyx viagra without a doctor prescription rjrl viagra results photos https://clck.ru/GzL4B ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com 7ix6

walgreen viagra

47e4 http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">viagra viagra nasal spray zcyx viagra without a doctor prescription rjrl viagra results photos https://clck.ru/GzL4B ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com 7ix6

free viagra sample pack by mail

1pxn http://bit.do/eZpii ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com natural forms of viagra o0pp http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">viagra without a doctor prescription iqrp actual shelf life of viagra http://cort.as/-L2rr ">viagra 5bnv

free viagra sample pack by mail

1pxn http://bit.do/eZpii ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com natural forms of viagra o0pp http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">viagra without a doctor prescription iqrp actual shelf life of viagra http://cort.as/-L2rr ">viagra 5bnv

does viagra cause prostate cancer

83rb https://v.gd/AtnGTE ">sites chewing viagra khte http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">find more info q8w2 pfizer viagra price https://is.gd/ixm8gy ">viagra zr6u

best generic viagra review

8dfy http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">viagra without a doctor prescription viagra pills to buy 1bwb http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">viagra gpcb buy female viagra http://cutt.us/mmfb0 ">browse this site cn4d

best generic viagra review

8dfy http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">viagra without a doctor prescription viagra pills to buy 1bwb http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">viagra gpcb buy female viagra http://cutt.us/mmfb0 ">browse this site cn4d

non prescription viagra alternative

cos8 https://clck.ru/GzL4B ">official site viagra timeline vky7 viagra nsqa viagra penis size https://u.to/kX2wFQ ">viagra without a doctor prescription wlni

womens viagra over the counter

gwix http://cutt.us/mmfb0 ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com ban viagra tua7 http://bit.do/eZpii ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com tk4h reddit viagra online http://gul.ly/x8nto ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com c8nr

viagra and alcohol interaction

qg43 https://v.gd/AtnGTE ">her explanation buy viagra online from canada 7bkz http://alturl.com/v58am ">viagra without a doctor prescription c2g8 signs of viagra use http://bit.do/eZpii ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com v8jh

viagra vape

m2pd http://xurl.es/nw1gp ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com best viagra dose w4hg http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">viagra without a doctor prescription onku gas station viagra http://chilp.it/6e55c53 ">viagra 9sez

viagra vape

m2pd http://xurl.es/nw1gp ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com best viagra dose w4hg http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">viagra without a doctor prescription onku gas station viagra http://chilp.it/6e55c53 ">viagra 9sez

can women use viagra

kkpn http://chilp.it/6e55c53 ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com free viagra sample pack by mail wgt3 http://xurl.es/nw1gp ">viagra without a doctor prescription exro utu viagra song by grandma http://url.ie/14ch9 ">viagra without a doctor prescription uqb6

super viagra

foaf http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com viagra memes mr4p http://url.ie/14ch9 ">my review here isnz pfizer viagra free sample http://cort.as/-L2rr ">viagra without a doctor prescription j1oo

viagra connect price

n90h http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com does cvs sell viagra pqf2 http://bit.do/eZpii ">visit this website w4j4 how long does it take for viagra to kick in http://gul.ly/x8nto ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com tepb

viagra connect price

n90h http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com does cvs sell viagra pqf2 http://bit.do/eZpii ">visit this website w4j4 how long does it take for viagra to kick in http://gul.ly/x8nto ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com tepb

what is the generic name for viagra

usxl http://xurl.es/nw1gp ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com viagra pills cvs 6i2r http://chilp.it/6e55c53 ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com eaox free samples of viagra or cialis http://cutt.us/mmfb0 ">web z7ya

organic viagra alternative

mj5w http://cort.as/-L2rr ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com goodrx viagra bqw1 http://alturl.com/v58am ">viagra without a doctor prescription mxiw what is the difference between sildenafil and viagra? http://gul.ly/x8nto ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com slxs

how to obtain viagra

ee7o viagra without a doctor prescription viagra prices at walmart vo09 http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">viagra without a doctor prescription 2sbi natural alternative to viagra http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com gms2

dosage for viagra

ijiy https://is.gd/ixm8gy ">viagra jenskaya viagra u81d http://bit.do/eZpii ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com 448j how much does viagra cost with insurance http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com lmm7

dosage for viagra

ijiy https://is.gd/ixm8gy ">viagra jenskaya viagra u81d http://bit.do/eZpii ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com 448j how much does viagra cost with insurance http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com lmm7

cenforce 100 vs viagra

zu0y http://alturl.com/v58am ">description viagra alternative gnc c9we http://alturl.com/v58am ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com 6qmy what is female viagra http://url.ie/14ch9 ">her explanation gcba

pfizer viagra discounts

hxd6 https://v.gd/AtnGTE ">viagra does medicare cover viagra 2016 ixi1 http://alturl.com/v58am ">helpful hints hbsx standard viagra dosage http://url.ie/14ch9 ">viagra without a doctor prescription o22t

online prescriptions for viagra

y4gz http://alturl.com/v58am ">internet healthy man viagra reviews ql11 https://u.to/kX2wFQ ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com jnly viagra rite aid check this 4dwa

cheap viagra no prescription

25g7 http://bit.do/eZpii ">Go Here cheapest viagra online tpbd viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com foej buy viagra online canadian pharmacy https://clck.ru/GzL4B ">viagra iicb

cheap viagra no prescription

25g7 http://bit.do/eZpii ">Go Here cheapest viagra online tpbd viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com foej buy viagra online canadian pharmacy https://clck.ru/GzL4B ">viagra iicb

strongest viagra pill

jbnq http://cort.as/-L2rr ">more information viagra natural para mujeres pxsm http://cort.as/-L2rr ">anchor 8nsg how much does viagra cost per pill http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">original site 8j5o

strongest viagra pill

jbnq http://cort.as/-L2rr ">more information viagra natural para mujeres pxsm http://cort.as/-L2rr ">anchor 8nsg how much does viagra cost per pill http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">original site 8j5o

free samples of viagra

zkvp viagra without a doctor prescription natural viagra pills b2ki http://cutt.us/mmfb0 ">viagra rgkv cialis viagra online http://chilp.it/6e55c53 ">you can try here 2p83

free samples of viagra

zkvp viagra without a doctor prescription natural viagra pills b2ki http://cutt.us/mmfb0 ">viagra rgkv cialis viagra online http://chilp.it/6e55c53 ">you can try here 2p83

viagra ad girl

lp4r he has a good point printable viagra coupon velk http://bit.do/eZpii ">viagra without a doctor prescription c9j2 is viagra funded by the government http://xurl.es/nw1gp ">address 8jjn

viagra with alcohol

km5f https://is.gd/ixm8gy ">viagra what happens when a woman takes male viagra hxcd https://clck.ru/GzL4B ">useful link qz2p viagra connect https://clck.ru/GzL4B ">find out here 9hwt

viagra stopped working

70wq pop over to this web-site viagra paypal accepted kqhq https://v.gd/AtnGTE ">viagra without a doctor prescription ef7l pictures of viagra http://chilp.it/6e55c53 ">go to these guys q18z

viagra 25mg

6xio http://alturl.com/v58am ">check viagra commercials youtube s1oh https://v.gd/AtnGTE ">viagra zs6h can you take viagra more than once a day http://cort.as/-L2rr ">my company 4cy7

man takes viagra

li9s http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">try this website pills like viagra at walmart sr0z http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">her latest blog ex4e man takes viagra http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">viagra without a doctor prescription nd1v

man takes viagra

li9s http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">try this website pills like viagra at walmart sr0z http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">her latest blog ex4e man takes viagra http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">viagra without a doctor prescription nd1v

do porn stars take viagra

fqn6 http://chilp.it/6e55c53 ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com son takes viagra 8m1l https://v.gd/AtnGTE ">visit this page 6695 generic viagra online reviews http://0rz.tw/KUS3i ">Learn More Here sxnh

viagra time

nboo https://is.gd/ixm8gy ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com over the counter viagra usa nw7w http://bit.do/eZpii ">viagra without a doctor prescription terk generic viagra for men http://cort.as/-L2rr ">visit this page 7omj

viagra to last longer

m2xe http://cutt.us/mmfb0 ">viagra viagra nitrates 9yfq http://cutt.us/mmfb0 ">viagra 98j8 viagra precio mexico viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com tmpr

viagra on a pole match

wyxw http://bit.do/eZpii ">viagra cheap viagra pills online j2mq http://gul.ly/x8nto ">try this out qnt8 purchase generic viagra https://u.to/kX2wFQ ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com uqnh

is viagra a controlled substance

b8h7 http://chilp.it/6e55c53 ">useful content viagra womens 7wkz viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com v53k what drugs are contraindicated with viagra http://soo.gd/kn4Q ">viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com qt3w

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <i> <blockquote> <p> <address> <pre> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <br> <b>

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Drug War Issues

Criminal JusticeAsset Forfeiture, Collateral Sanctions (College Aid, Drug Taxes, Housing, Welfare), Court Rulings, Drug Courts, Due Process, Felony Disenfranchisement, Incarceration, Policing (2011 Drug War Killings, 2012 Drug War Killings, 2013 Drug War Killings, 2014 Drug War Killings, 2015 Drug War Killings, 2016 Drug War Killings, 2017 Drug War Killings, Arrests, Eradication, Informants, Interdiction, Lowest Priority Policies, Police Corruption, Police Raids, Profiling, Search and Seizure, SWAT/Paramilitarization, Task Forces, Undercover Work), Probation or Parole, Prosecution, Reentry/Rehabilitation, Sentencing (Alternatives to Incarceration, Clemency and Pardon, Crack/Powder Cocaine Disparity, Death Penalty, Decriminalization, Defelonization, Drug Free Zones, Mandatory Minimums, Rockefeller Drug Laws, Sentencing Guidelines)CultureArt, Celebrities, Counter-Culture, Music, Poetry/Literature, Television, TheaterDrug UseParaphernalia, ViolenceIntersecting IssuesCollateral Sanctions (College Aid, Drug Taxes, Housing, Welfare), Violence, Border, Budgets/Taxes/Economics, Business, Civil Rights, Driving, Economics, Education (College Aid), Employment, Environment, Families, Free Speech, Gun Policy, Human Rights, Immigration, Militarization, Money Laundering, Pregnancy, Privacy (Search and Seizure, Drug Testing), Race, Religion, Science, Sports, Women's IssuesMarijuana PolicyGateway Theory, Hemp, Marijuana -- Personal Use, Marijuana Industry, Medical MarijuanaMedicineMedical Marijuana, Science of Drugs, Under-treatment of PainPublic HealthAddiction, Addiction Treatment (Science of Drugs), Drug Education, Drug Prevention, Drug-Related AIDS/HIV or Hepatitis C, Harm Reduction (Methadone & Other Opiate Maintenance, Needle Exchange, Overdose Prevention, Pill Testing, Safer Injection Sites)Source and Transit CountriesAndean Drug War, Coca, Hashish, Mexican Drug War, Opium ProductionSpecific DrugsAlcohol, Ayahuasca, Cocaine (Crack Cocaine), Ecstasy, Heroin, Ibogaine, ketamine, Khat, Kratom, Marijuana (Gateway Theory, Marijuana -- Personal Use, Medical Marijuana, Hashish), Methamphetamine, New Synthetic Drugs (Synthetic Cannabinoids, Synthetic Stimulants), Nicotine, Prescription Opiates (Fentanyl, Oxycontin), Psilocybin / Magic Mushrooms, Psychedelics (LSD, Mescaline, Peyote, Salvia Divinorum)YouthGrade School, Post-Secondary School, Raves, Secondary School