CHANGING MINDS, LAWS & LIVES CAMPAIGN

About DRCNetStop the Drug War (DRCNet) is an international organization working for an end to drug prohibition worldwide and for interim policy reform in US drug laws and criminal justice system. Read more about DRCNet.

Make a Donation

Want to stop the drug war? One way to help is to make a generous donation -- member support makes up a critical portion of our budget, and we can't do it without you!

some organizations DRCNet played a role in starting:


You Can't Win the Drug War if Alcohol is Legal

Did you hear about this wild booze riot in Michigan? The massive unruly crowd hurled bottles at the cops, who had to launch tear gas grenades just to break the thing up. Pete Guither observed hilariously that no one ever throws bongs and rolling papers at police. He's right, they don't.

Advocates for drug policy reform are fond of pointing out the hypocrisy of permitting limitless consumption of riot-inducing alcohol, while banning silly things like marijuana that make people draw pictures or eat nachos. And that's a legitimate point to make, as far as it goes. But it is rarely observed that the legality of alcohol, by its very nature, plays an important role in undermining other drug enforcement efforts.

For decades, illicit drug users have found cover amidst throngs of raging drunks. Alcohol is just stronger than most other recreational drugs. A decent percentage of alcohol users can just be counted on to go berserk at their preferred dosage, leading to screaming, fighting, vandalism, clumsy sex, and so on. It's not just stupid to arrest pot smokers in the midst of all this, it's impossible.

The pot smokers are the ones that get away when a party is raided. They're the ones chatting at a table in the corner while your drunk girlfriend is dancing on the bar. They're the ones that get home without incident on a Saturday night. You'll never find them puking or punching each other, so you'd better test their urine or catch 'em in a cloud of smoke, otherwise you'll never know what's up.

It's not a crime to be wasted as long as you found your buzz in a bottle not a bag, thus police have no authority to act simply because everyone in your house looks messed up. Instead, drug arrests happen primarily through the intrusive and time-consuming methods of sting operations and widespread consent searches. You can put bodies behind bars this way, but not nearly enough to win the war.

As long as it remains legal to get utterly obliterated on booze, the enforcement of other drug laws won't just look stupid and hypocritical. It won't even work.

Drug War Issues Violence

Alcohol Industry keeps drug reformers off the air

The irony and hypocrisy is apparent when you compare the harm between alcohol and illicit drugs. However, the alcohol industry represents something much more dangerous. They are part of the reason you rarely see drug reformer's message on TV. Why do you think the alcohol industry funds groups like the Partnership for a Drug-Free America? Because they want to keep their illegal competitors off the air and they have done quite an effective job on that front.

I work for a anti-DWI group and when we first started we were on all the major national TV talkshows. Once we joined the SMART(Stop Marketing Alcohol on Radio & TV) we were immediately black ball from the national scene and have found it very hard to get bookings on TV shows to this day. So the alcohol industry is much more powerful than they are percieved by the public. They profit from the drug war and yet receive little scrutiny for it. I applaud Scott for writing about alcohol on his blog, but he doesn't go far enough to point out the relationship between alcohol and getting our message out on the airways.

Thanks

I agree that to whatever extent the alcohol industry is involved in supporting the continued criminalization of other drugs, that is just awful.

But we should keep in mind that the people running the alcohol industry today are preferable to those who ran it under prohibition. Moreover, for all the problems alcohol causes, it is still enjoyed responsibly by the overwhelming majority of its users. I'm skeptical of any policy which restricts legitimate access for many in order to curb problematic use by a few.

Prohibition is not the answer

As bad as alcohol is, Prohibition does not work. If a real crime happens that needs to be dealt with but nothing positive happens through prohibition of any drug, Alcohol prohibition created crime and violence that was off the scale just like drug prohibition has.The year alcohol prohibition was repealed violent crime fell 65%. Legal or not people are going to get a buzz, all prohibition does is create a black market where crime and violence thrive. Drug policy reform groups have the tools in place to change the laws, so keep up to date on current legislation and get ALL your associates to join you in contacting elected representatives at the local, state and federal level. Here's a site you might want to visit:
JUST SAY KNOW to the DRUG WAR
If you're using Internet Explorer web browser use this link: http://jsknow.angelfire.com/home
If you're using any other web browser use this link: http://jsknow.angelfire.com/index.html

Not accurate

"But it is rarely observed that the legality of alcohol, by its very nature, plays an important role in undermining other drug enforcement efforts."

Actually, it's not uncommon to find drugs on people arrested for public intoxication or DWI from alcohol (particulary marijuana), because police often ask these people when making the arrest if they have anything illegal on them. Of course, you are correct that consent searches aid in marijuana arrests, but it's often another violation occuring in the public arena (most often a minor traffic violation and perhaps computer check for warrants) that triggers a suspect's detainment. If officers smell marijuana, and perhaps observe other corroborating evidence (e.g. a pipe or baggie of leafy substance), this can lead to a probable cause search and subsequent marijuana arrest. In other words, the vast majority of marijuana violations often occur due to carelessness of the user in the public arena, but these marijuana arrests have little deterrent effect on the vast majority of the millions of marijuana users, who use responsibly and safely in private settings every year.

So?

All of this would still happen if alcohol were illegal. Marijuana users would still be searched incident to an alcohol-related arrest. There would still be DUI checkpoints, possibly more of them. Arrestees would be encouraged to flip on their suppliers, resulting in more arrests and more searches.

Remember, my point was that the legality of alcohol undermines drug enforcement, not just alcohol in general.

Your point...

...was about public intoxication getting out of hand (as was the news report) and my point was that there are laws in most college towns that prohibit such behavior and often serve to enhance drug enforcement.

If alcohol were illegal, the marijuana market would be undermined because the new gold rush for organized crime would be with booze and its 100+ million consumers, not growing weeds in some national forest for a much smaller consumer market.

Fair enough

I think it would easier to bust people for drugs generally if alcohol intoxication didn't constantly blur the line between legal and illegal wastedness, but you're right that alcohol violations can become a pretext for the discovery of other contraband. Of course, the harsher our alcohol laws become, the more such pretexts will be created.

As for the latter point, I don't know and I hope we'll never find out.

Why not both! Gourmet cannabis with a fine imported beer?

"As long as it remains legal to get utterly obliterated on booze, the enforcement of other drug laws won't just look stupid and hypocritical. It won't even work."

I agree; show us the consistency in the general laws protecting public health. People are allowed to consume dangerous foods, dangerious liquids, and dangerous cigarettes, not to mention dangerious products like guns and ATVs. We call this freedom. But what is up with illegal 'herb?' Bam out of nowhere... among a multitude of hazardous to your health products is that lonely old devil weed. The (forbidden fruit) "take away" approach is by human nature a guaranteed way to create takers. This is the big mistake the Drug War is making. But when people have a freedom and can take it for granted, boredom sets in. This is where the legal alcohol manufactures need to push their drugs with media commercials, therefore 'bewitching' unsuspecting users to gain marketshare.

If the drug warriors really wanted to lower marijuana use they would make it legal to consume (end the black market), but ban all media commercials to promote use. So the alcohol manufactures don't have to compete with air-time, a real unfair advantage! Then maybe people might start seeing TV beer commercials similar to the old pushers on the street?

Sometimes it is hard to

Sometimes it is hard to express your disgust toward Government sponsered intrusions.
In this country you don't have a free will or the right to choose what you ingest. Period. Every week some new Prescription drug gets pulled off the market because of it's lethal side effects. Alcohol & tobacco have their fair share of casualties. Yet Government thru legalization has herded it's nation of citizens toward alcohol, tobacco and the Pharmacy's Russian Roulette of pills. The U.S. has created a monopoly of recreational consumables.
The riots in Michigan have placed a microscope on alcohol use and the downside society faces when large crowds of "drunk & uncontrollable" people do what they have been given the right to do. No large crowd of pot smokers would get as out of control as these Government sponsered Partyers. As quoted online "Pot smokers would not be throwing weed bags, bongs and rolling papers"!
Whether a substance is legal or not does not detract from the fact that unruly behaviour is unacceptable and should be punished. It is when our laws allow for the use of one substance while criminalizing the use of a clearly more benign substance that reality is distorted and mistrust sets in.

We can't trust our leaders anymore when it comes to the Billions spent on a misguided Drug war that has done little more than disintegrate our civil liberties.

We can't trust our leaders anymore when it comes to the Billions spent on a misguided Drug war that has done little more than disintegrate our civil liberties.

"We can't trust our leaders anymore..."

Well spoken!

You're Right!

You are all right, alcohol should be illegal also. As a matter-of-fact I seem to remember that it was??? Oh Yeah, We just gave up. Just because we can't enforce a law doesn't make it wrong. There is too much evidence of all the harm that drugs (including alcohol) do.

Submit to Congress the "All or None" Bill

We should push for an alcohol prohibition bill to see how many sponsors you get for it, since one of the major prohibitionist reasons for not making marijuana legal is that we have enough problems with alcohol and that it would send the wrong message to kids. So lets write a bill and see how many alcohol supremacists sponsor it so we can start sending the "right message to kids".

Stupid Cannabis Laws

A miracle plant that has been bashed over and over.
Totally irrational behavior demonizing a non-toxic beneficial chemical--cannabinoids!

Don't Bogart Me.

Hit da BONG!

I'LL SMOKE WEED WHENEVER I WANT, THE COPS CAN KISS MY BONG! IF I GET ARRESTED AND GO TO JAIL I'LL DO MY TIME AND WHEN I GET OUT - I WILL HIT THE BONG AGAIN. IT IS CRAZY TO MAKE WEED AGAINST THE LAW. THEY CALL ME A DOPER. BUT I THINK PEOPLE WHO WANT TO MAKE WEED AGAINST THE LAW ARE DOPES. HA HA

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <i> <blockquote> <p> <address> <pre> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may post code using <code>...</code> (generic) or <?php ... ?> (highlighted PHP) tags.
  • Web and e-mail addresses are automatically converted into links.
More information about formatting options Captcha Image: you will need to recognize the text in it.
Please type in the letters/numbers that are shown in the image above.